Black, White, and Gray All Over - A Memoir of Resilience and Truth

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 

Black, White, and Gray All Over is both a personal memoir and a chronicle of a city and a profession, told with an immediacy that makes you feel as though you’ve been invited into the passenger seat for a years-long ride-along. Frederick Reynolds writes with the economy of a seasoned storyteller, sketching people, places, and moments with just enough detail to make them vivid without ever slowing the pace.

 

From the turbulent 1960s, through the shifting social and political landscapes of the ’70s and ’80s, to the present day, Reynolds takes us through a life lived in service—and in struggle—within the Compton Police Department. We meet an array of characters: fellow officers, community members, victims, and perpetrators, all rendered as more than just names on a page. Compton itself becomes a living, breathing character—wounded, resilient, and endlessly complex.

What makes Reynolds’s story even more compelling is his personal journey. He did not come from an easy beginning—his early years were marked by family dysfunction, alcoholism, and instability. Yet, he rose above those challenges, carving out a path defined by discipline, perseverance, and a willingness to confront the darkness, both on the streets and within himself. His growth over the years is as much a part of this memoir as the crimes he investigated or the history he witnessed.

This is not a memoir that seeks to glorify, nor one that aims to condemn. Instead, it’s an unflinching yet compassionate look at what it means to serve in a broken system, to witness both the worst and the best of humanity. The book acknowledges the violence, hardship, and moral gray areas that come with police work, but those moments are never gratuitous—they’re presented with purpose and context.

Reynolds also weaves in moments of levity and tenderness: the camaraderie among officers, small acts of kindness from unexpected places, and glimpses of his life beyond the badge. These moments provide a necessary counterpoint to the heavier material, reminding us that humanity persists even in the toughest environments.

By the time I reached the last page, I felt I’d not only read one man’s story, but also witnessed the evolution of a life—from troubled beginnings to a hard-earned wisdom. Black, White, and Gray All Over is powerful, memorable, and well worth the read, especially for those interested in the intersection of personal history and broader social change. It’s a testament to resilience, integrity, and the belief that where you start does not have to determine where you finish.

 

Memoir delivered with humor to ease the pain & a heart full of forgiveness that brings hope

Shake that Cream: Battling Gods and Monsters in the Backwoods of East Texas by Ellen Black weaves the warp and weft threads of her past into a tapestry depicting an abusive childhood growing up in a dysfunctional household that joined Herbert W. Armstrong’s Worldwide Church of God cult in the late 1950s as well as her lifelong quest to escape to normal.

 

Black chronicles events growing up in small-town Texas, attending Herbert W’s church and school. As a bonus negative, her father also taught at the school and knew her every move. Nowhere in her childhood did she receive affirmation, encouragement, or love. Yet, while she longed for it and lived in a sea of disappointment, she hung on to hope that somehow eventually her parents would love her.

When she goes away to college and graduates, she finally escapes the clutches of the church and her parents, but does she really? What happens when her racist parents learn she has a bi-racial child outside of marriage? They travel to New York City to kidnap her baby daughter and in a blink, the nightmare stands at her door again.

Shake that Cream is a moving, highly readable, firsthand account of what Black underwent being raised in the Worldwide Church of God cult. She articulates how Armstrong influenced her parents and so many others. While the details are disturbing, even as Black describes the abuse she and her brother suffered, this enthralling and harrowing memoir carries the reader on a journey of hope through a quagmire of false Christian doctrines, control, abuse, lies, anger, and more. Shake that Cream masterfully weaves Ellen’s story in a way that lays out her dire situation but doesn’t get mired in the negative. She tells her story from the first-person point of view and delivers it with enough humor to help ease the pain, and a heart full of forgiveness that brings hope. She not only escaped but survived with her sense of self intact and the toxic cycle broken.

I recommend Shake that Cream to the cult curious, those interested in secret societies, and false religions, and those trying to learn more about the Worldwide Church of God. I also recommend it to other survivors who have grown up with such physical and emotional pain and are trying to find their way to their own new normal. I award this book a strong four stars.

 

As Book Hookup, I am a longtime book reviewer, and I received a free review copy of this book and have not been compensated for reviewing or recommending it. This review is posted in collaboration with BookTasters. Some links in this post are affiliate links. We participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to amazon.com and affiliate sites.